| 2023 | D. Viojo-Rainbow | Werribee Districts |
| 2022 | D. Viojo-Rainbow | Werribee Districts |
| 2021 | S. Brewer | Caroline Springs |
| 2019 | D. Kovacevic | St Albans |
| 2018 | C. Endres | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2017 | S. Kennedy | Altona |
| 2016 | K. McHarg | Deer Park |
| 2015 | W. Skipper | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2014 | M. Dean | Werribee Districts |
| 2013 | C. O'Keefe | Spotswood* |
| S. Broadbent | Deer Park* | |
| 2012 | C. O'Keefe | Spotswood |
| 2011 | T. Jenkins | St Albans |
| 2010 | T. Jenkins | St Albans |
| 2009 | D. Jacobs | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 2008 | B. Julier | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 2007 | R. Douglas | Sunshine |
| 2006 | J. Clarke | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 2005 | S. Arena | St Albans |
| 2004 | D. Galea | Spotswood |
| 2003 | G. McGaw | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2002 | A. Ibrahim | St Albans |
| 2001 | J. Fitzpatrick | St Albans |
| 2000 | C. Barker | West Footscray* |
| S. Sir | Parkside* | |
| 1999 | A. Venner | Altona* |
| A. Thege | Spotswood* | |
| 1998 | A. Venner | Altona |
| 1997 | M. Frost | Yarraville |
| 1996 | M. Frost | Yarraville |
| 1995 | F. Zoccali | Parkside |
| 1994 | C. McKellin | Deer Park |
| 1993 | M. Kriehn | Spotswood |
| 1992 | D. Pevitt | Spotswood |
| 1991 | S. Moss | Deer Park |
| 1990 | S. Moss | Deer Park |
| 1989 | G. Brown | Spotswood |
| 1988 | J. Taylor | Albion |
| 1987 | P. Eudey | Spotswood* |
| M. Phelan | West Footscray* | |
| 1986 | J. Theodoridis | Albion* |
| B. Caulfield | Wembley Park* | |
| 1985 | P. Mildenhall | Spotswood |
| 1984 | M. Hewat | Braybrook |
| 1983 | R. Peterson | St Albans |
| 1982 | G. Hodges | Seddon |
| 1981 | J. Blyth | St Albans |
| 1980 | M. Komp | Parkside |
| 1979 | A. Ebeyer | North Footscray |
| 1978 | L. Hawkins | Braybrook |
| 1977 | J. Narres | Deer Park |
| 1976 | D. Brown | Seddon |
| 1975 | B. Priest | Braybrook |
| 1974 | B. Chamberlain | Seddon |
| 1973 | B. Priest | Braybrook |
| 1972 | G. Gingell | Kingsville |
| 1971 | T. Flint | North Footscray |
| 1970 | R. Beattie | Parkside |
| 1969 | D. Knight | ICI (Deer Park) |
| 1968 | R. Smithwick | North Footscray |
| 1967 | A. McAssey | Spotswood |
| 1966 | G. Saunders | Braybrook |
| 1965 | D. Prior | Albion |
| 1964 | A. Bottomley | West Newport |
| 1963 | J. Charles | North Footscray |
| 1962 | J. Gaylor | Albion |
| 1961 | R. Murray | North Footscray |
| 1960 | A. Clough | Seddon |
| 1959 | L. Charles | West Newport |
| 1958 | L. Anderson | Kingsville |
| 1957 | M. Beckett | F & Y Socials |
| 1956 | H. Bolger | West Footscray |
| 1955 | L. Charles | West Footscray |
| 1954 | M. Beckett | F & Y Socials |
| 1953 | R. Jewell | Seddon |
| 1952 | E. Spence | North Footscray |
| 1951 | R. Smith | Seddon |
| 1950 | K. Cooke | West Footscray |
| 1949 | B. Murray | Parkside* |
| B. Brown | Spotswood* | |
| 1948 | H. Mason | Seddon |
| 1947 | R. Jewell | Seddon |
| 1946 | A. Mathieson | Essendon Districts |
| 1945 | R. Cooke | 6th Melb Scouts |
| 1944 | S. Fox | Parkside |
| 1943 | D. Taylor | 6th Melb Scouts |
| 1942 | G. McLaren | South Footscray |
| 1941 | E.J. Wilkinson | Seddon |
| 1940 | K. McGrath | Seddon |
| 1939 | H. Dolphin | 6th Melb Scouts |
| 1938 | J. Flint | West Footscray |
| 1937 | N. Honey | ICI (Deer Park) |
| 1936 | T. Laffan | Parkside |
| 1935 | J. Ryan | Seddon |
| 1934 | F. Barker | 6th Melb Scouts |
| 1933 | J. Sainsbury | Parkside |
| 1932 | C. Mathieson | West Footscray |
| 1931 | A.G Thomson | Footscray Scouts |
*Joint winners
| 2023 | B. Spiteri | Werribee Districts |
| 2022 | C. Scudamore | Werribee Districts |
| 2021 | R. Kitchen | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2019 | B. Kitchen | Hoppers Crossing* |
| B. Morton | Werribee Districts* | |
| 2018 | M. Mitoiu | St Albans |
| 2017 | A. Law | Werribee Districts |
| 2016 | B. Miller | Altona |
| 2015 | B. Miller | Altona |
| 2014 | B. Miller | Altona |
| 2013 | B. Miller | Altona |
| 2012 | B. Miller | Altona |
| 2011 | M. Ergunen | Spotswood* |
| A. Williams | Hoppers Crossing* | |
| 2010 | A. Hodgetts | Altona |
| 2009 | M. Burns | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 2008 | A. Moore | Albion |
| 2007 | D. Coleman | Spotswood |
| 2006 | B. Tyquin | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2005 | J. Scott | St Albans* |
| M. Brasher | Albion* | |
| 2004 | P. Eudey | Sunshine |
| 2003 | B. Franksen | Albion |
| 2002 | C. Clonan | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2001 | G. Evans | Altona |
| 2000 | S. Balshaw | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 1999 | G. Evans | Altona* |
| B. McQuade | Port Melbourne Colts* | |
| 1998 | J. Ryan | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 1997 | D. Gill | Yarraville |
| 1996 | G. Sperling | Yarraville |
| 1995 | R. Patterson | St Albans |
| 1994 | P. Michetti | St Albans |
| 1993 | G. Sperling | Kingsville* |
| L. D’Ambrosio | Seddon* | |
| 1992 | L. D’Ambrosio | Seddon |
| 1991 | D. Scott | Spotswood |
| 1990 | W. Dalton | Spotswood |
| 1989 | G. Langlands | Spotswood |
| 1988 | G. Bate | Albion |
| 1987 | A. Hunt | Kingsville* |
| Greg Spurling | North Footscray* | |
| 1986 | G. Bate | Albion |
| 1985 | B. Kenny | Kingsville |
| 1984 | L. Croft | Sunshine YCW |
| 1983 | D. Nelson | Deer Park |
| 1982 | M. Igoe | Sunshine YCW |
| 1981 | B. Bourke | West Footscray |
| 1980 | P. Hockey | Sunshine YCW |
| 1979 | B. Hall | West Footscray |
| 1978 | J. Barker | Kingsville |
| 1977 | A. Hall | Albion |
| 1976 | R. Campbell | Seddon |
| 1975 | J. Anderson | North Footscray |
| 1974 | D. Thompson | Seddon |
| 1973 | W. Trusler | Albion |
| 1972 | D. Tipping | Braybrook |
| 1971 | A. (Wal) Saunders | Kingsville |
| 1970 | G. Hollingworth | West Footscray |
| 1969 | R. Simmons | Braybrook |
| 1968 | C. Gibbons | Braybrook |
| 1967 | C. Gibbons | Braybrook |
*Joint winners
| 2023 | S. Campbell | Parkside |
| 2022 | S. Campbell | Parkside |
| 2021 | S. Campbell | Parkside |
| 2019 | K. Bharathi | Yarraville Seddon Eagles |
| 2018 | N. Montague | Manor Lakes |
| 2017 | B. Mesto | Newport Power |
| 2016 | K. Murphy | North Footscray |
| 2015 | D.Ellis | Wyndhamvale |
| 2014 | C. Muratore | Parkside |
| 2013 | J. Lampi | Sanctuary Lakes |
| 2012 | R. Ford | Parkside |
| 2011 | R. Trajkovski | Deer Park |
| 2010 | L. Summers | Deer Park |
| 2009 | N. Juegan | Parkside |
| 2008 | M. Kennedy | Western Magpies |
| 2007 | L. Braun | Braybrook |
| 2006 | R. Telfer | North Sunshine |
| 2005 | S. Lane | West Footscray* |
| 2005 | G. Frankel | Deer Park* |
| 2004 | D. Williams | North Footscray |
| 2003 | G. Frankel | Deer Park* |
| 2003 | D. Williams | North Footscray* |
| 2002 | J. McCallion | Kensington Hill Hammerheads |
| 2001 | B. Evans | Seddon/Yarraville Club |
| 2000 | K. Robertson | Sunshine Heights |
| 1999 | P. Maynard | North Sunshine* |
| 1999 | S. Carroll | North Sunshine* |
| 1998 | L.D'Ambrosio | Seddon/ Yarraville |
| 1997 | J. Rankin | Coburg Districts |
| 1996 | B. Cook | Glen Orden |
| 1995 | D. Gray | Sunshine YCW |
| 1994 | D. Page | Albion* |
| 1994 | M. Sammut | Ascot Vale* |
| 1993 | D. Page | Albion* |
| 1993 | S. Rayment | North Essendon |
| 1992 | P. Quinn | Coburg Districts |
| 1991 | S. Rayment | North Essendon* |
| 1991 | B. Tuppen | West Newport* |
| 1990 | E. Muench | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 1989 | P. Michetti | Sunshine Heights |
| 1988 | R. Pereira | Ascot Vale* |
| 1988 | C. Ottenbach | Ascot Vale* |
| 1987 | G. Davis | A.N.B.Y |
| 1986 | G. Kelly | Braybrook YCW |
| 1951 | K. Blacker | Williamstown Rovers |
| 1950 | K. Wood | Vic Socials |
| 1949 | G. McCann | Williamstown Rovers* |
| 1949 | A. McVeith | 6th Melb Scouts |
| 1948 | W. McKenzie | Vic Socials |
| 1947 | S. Wallis | Waratah |
| 1946 | H. Self | Waratah |
| 1945 | K. Webb | Sunshine |
| 1944 | S. Bell | Yarraville Boys |
| 1943 | W. Sheehan | Newport CYMS |
| 1942 | H. Hickey | South Footscray |
| 1941 | F. Kenny | Kingsville |
| 1940 | A. King | St Andrews |
| 1939 | G. Tribe | C.S.R |
| 1938 | H. Hickey | South Footscray |
| 1937 | W.Warden | Kingsville |
| 1936 | H. Hickey | South Footscray |
| 1935 | B. Richards | Spotswood |
| 1934 | A. Self | Baptist |
| 2023 | T. Waring | Sunshine |
| 2022 | A. Gauci | Parkside |
| 2021 | T. Pearce | Point Cook Centrals |
| 2019 | S. Miller | Yarraville Seddon Eagles |
| 2018 | J. Collard | Parkside |
| 2017 | L. Styles | Manor Lakes |
| 2016 | M. Bellingham | North Footscray |
| 2015 | M. Saker | Caroline Springs* |
| S. Ingham | Wyndhamvale* | |
| 2014 | B. Ashman | Parkside |
| 2013 | M. Raak | Caroline Springs |
| 2012 | P. May | Braybrook* |
| M. Allouche | Yarraville Seddon Eagles* | |
| 2011 | A. Haddara | Parkside* |
| P. Growcott | Albanvale* | |
| 2010 | P.Growcott | Albanvale |
| 2009 | C. Hough | Coburg Districts |
| 2008 | M. Dolny | Albanvale |
| 2007 | M. Dolny | Albanvale |
| 2006 | T. Minutolo | Coburg Districts |
| 2005 | A. Hodgetts | Altona |
| 2004 | T. Minutolo | Coburg Districts |
| 2003 | N. Pistikakis | Western Magpies |
| 2002 | H. Phan | North Sunshine |
| 2001 | H. Phan | North Sunshine |
| 2000 | D. Murphy | Glenorden |
| 1999 | T. Danskin | Braybrook |
| 1998 | P. Russell | Braybrook |
| 1997 | P. Sheldon | Coburg Districts |
| 1996 | S. Butterworth | Fawkner Amateurs |
| 1995 | M. Barrett | Fawkner Amateurs |
| 1994 | S. Ivkovic | Albion |
| 1993 | T. Jedrojewski | East Brunswick |
| 1992 | R. Kitchen | Hoppers Crossing |
| 1991 | L. Bomford | North Essendon |
| 1990 | M. Flynn | Coburg Districts |
| 1989 | J. Vellani | Ascot Vale* |
| 1989 | I. Montomery | Hoppers Crossing* |
| P.Robertson | North Sunshine* | |
| 1988 | M. Marmo | Central Altona |
| 1987 | K. Jackson | Sandridge |
| 1986 | D. Prior | Deer Park |
*Indicates joint winner
| 2023 | D. Hovey | Suns |
| 2022 | L. Montrose | Albanvale |
| 2021 | J. Tomelty | Wyndham Suns |
| 2019 | T. Lawrie | Tarneit |
| 2018 | B. Sheean | Point Cook Centrals |
| 2017 | D. Hovey | Wyndham Suns* |
| J. Cloke | Parkside* | |
| 2016 | T. Lawrie | Tarneit |
| 2015 | B. Ashman | Parkside |
| 2014 | L. Wallace | Braybrook |
| 1998 | K. Robertson | Sunshine Heights |
| 1997 | T. Fulton | Brunswick Amateurs |
| 1996 | R. Moloney | West Newport |
| 1995 | P. Barlow | Wembley Park |
| 1994 | S. Zahra | Laverton |
| 1993 | B. Regan | Wembley Park |
| 1992 | T. Phillips | Flemington |
| 1991 | A. White | Wyndhamvale |
| 1990 | A. White | Wyndhamvale |
| 1989 | J. Crouch | Laverton |
| 1988 | M. Williams | Braybrook YCW |
*Joint winners
| 2023 | A. Campbell | Tarneit |
| 2022 | J. Granger | North Sunshine |
| 2021 | D. Thomas | Albanvale |
| 2019 | T. Sinclair | Braybrook |
| 2018 | R. Frost | Tarneit |
| 2017 | J. Cowlishaw | Tarneit |
| 2016 | C. Stephens | Wyndham Suns |
| 2015 | G. Jones | Wyndham Suns |
| 2014 | G. Jones | Sanctuary Lakes |
| 1998 | S. Dunn | Brunswick Amateurs |
| 1997 | M. Foss | Kealba |
| 1996 | G. Grist | Laverton* |
| J. Darcy | Laverton* | |
| 1995 | M. Hartshorne | Laverton |
| 1994 | G. Greaney | North Essendon |
| 1993 | M. Harris | Wyndhamvale |
| 1992 | R. Brown | Newport* |
| B. Evans | Newlands Coburg* | |
| 1991 | D. Sheldrick | North Sunshine |
| 1990 | D. Gaul | A.N.B.Y |
| 1989 | E. De Francesco | Ascot Vale |
| 1988 | K. Jackson | Sandridge |
*Joint winners
| 2023 | M. Althouse | Spotswood |
| 2022 | D. Vasilevska | Caroline Springs |
| 2021 | K. Bays | Point Cook |
| 2019 | E. Duffy | West Footscray |
| 2018 | G. Anderson | Manor Lakes |
| 2017 | K. Raymundo* | Caroline Springs |
*Combined WRFL/EDFL Competition
| 2023 | C. Muus | Wyndhamvale |
| 2022 | M. Burton | Wyndhamvale |
| 2021 | C. Muus | Wyndhamvale |
| 1995 | C. Green | Sunshine YCW |
| 1994 | W. Kennedy | St Albans |
| A. Bradley | RAAF Melbourne | |
| M. Walker | RAAF Melbourne | |
| 1993 | J. Baars | Albion |
| 1992 | G. Kilty | Ascot Vale |
| 1991 | D. Anderson | Albion |
| 1990 | H. Peterson | Sandridge |
| T. Trimboli | St Albans | |
| 1989 | K. Jackson | Sandridge |
| 1988 | M. Woods | Albion |
| 1987 | C. Starr | St Albans |
| 1985 | E. Muench | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 1984 | S. Canov | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 1983 | A. Lutterschmidt | Old Ess. Grammar |
| 1982 | T. Rajmajer | Albanvale |
| 1981 | T. Rajmajer | Albanvale |
| 1980 | G. Nuske | Kingsville |
| 1979 | C. Davis | Kensington |
| 1979 | G. Taylor | KYMCA |
| 1985 | F. Cavarella | Nth Dists |
| 1984 | D. Barker | Kingsville |
| 1983 | B. French | EHSES |
| 1985 | J. Dearaugo | Albion |
| 2018 | J. Callaway | Altona |
| Z. Neicho | Caroline Springs | |
| B. Searle | Altona | |
| 2017 | E. Taylor | Altona |
| 2016 | B. Kitchen | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2016 | S. Woods | Werribee Districts |
| 2023 | C. Mullens | Point Cook |
| 2022 | B. Spiteri | Werribee Districts |
| 2021 | B. Spiteri | Werribee Districts |
| 2019 | E. Mantas | Caroline Springs |
| 2015 | N. Williams | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2014 | S. Ismail | Deer Park |
| 2013 | B. Kuypers | St Albans |
| 2012 | J. Lampi | Point Cook |
| 2011 | M. Poland | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2010 | J. McPherson | Albion |
| 2009 | A. Vivoda | Altona |
| 2008 | C. Lawson | Altona |
| 2007 | M. Hardiman | Altona |
| 2006 | R. Noye | Spotswood |
| 2005 | M. Nicolaides | Albion/Heights |
| 2004 | M. Cravino | Wyndhamvale Juniors |
| 2003 | S. Pace | Altona Juniors |
| 2002 | J. Charter | Albanvale |
| 2001 | L. Dennerley | Wyndhamvale Juniors |
| 2000 | M. Caruana | Sunshine Heights |
| 1999 | R. Cassidy | Altona |
| 1998 | J. McCabe | Sunshine YCW |
| 1997 | C. Simpkin | Sunshine YCW |
| 1996 | P. Battaglia | Hoppers Crossing |
| 1995 | J. Orsini | St Albans |
| 1994 | S. Cobovic | Port Melbourne Colts |
| 1993 | S. Carroll | Sunshine YCW |
| 1992 | J. Perrone | Spotswood |
| 1991 | D. Crea | North Footscray |
| 1971 | W. Bates | Footscray |
| 1970 | C. Kinniburgh | West Footscray |
| 1969 | M. Pokrovsky | St Albans |
| 1968 | R. Cole | F & Y Socials |
| 1967 | I. Grossman | North Footscray |
| 1966 | N. Ickeringill | Parkside |
| 1964 | H. McCauliffe | Spotswood |
| 1963 | K. Jackman | West Footscray |
| 1962 | D. Doll | F & Y Socials |
| 1961 | T. Parton | F & Y Socials |
| 1960 | F. Battestella | F & Y Socials |
| 1959 | R. Walker | Braybrook |
| 1958 | F. Ambrosy | WCYMS |
| K. Beamish | North Footscray | |
| 1957 | A. Saunders | Seddon |
| 1956 | J. Cairns | Spotswood |
| 1955 | D. McLean | F & Y Socials |
| 1954 | R. Hempel | Kingsville |
| 1953 | F. Soraghan | West Footscray |
| 1952 | B. Stockman | West Footscray |
| 1951 | W. Hughes | Spotswood |
| 1950 | E. Whitten | Braybrook |
| 1949 | C. Poole | Newport |
| 1948 | J. Jackson | Sunshine |
| 1947 | J.J. Storey | West Footscray |
| 1946 | A. Greelish | Spotswood |
| 1945 | M. McPherson | West Footscray |
| 1944 | L. Reid | Spotswood |
| 1943 | A. Mathieson | Combine |
| 1942 | M. Laffey | West Footscray |
| 1941 | J. Watters | North Footscray |
| 1940 | R. Cooke | North Melb |
| 1939 | C. McClelland | West Footscray |
| 1938 | M. McDonnell | West Footscray |
| 1937 | J. Flint | West Footscray |
| 1936 | J. Miller | North Footscray |
| 2023 | J. Elcheikh | Sunshine |
| 2022 | J. Elcheikh | Sunshine |
| 2021 | K. Logan | Point Cook |
| 2019 | K. Andrews | Werribee Centrals |
| 2015 | L. Scarborough | Wyndhamvale |
| 2014 | L. Scarborough | Wyndhamvale |
| 2013 | N. Johnson | Glen Orden |
| 2012 | J. Caterino | Albanvale |
| 2011 | J. Lampi | Point Cook |
| 2010 | J. Cameron | North Sunshine |
| 2009 | S. Hudson | Werribee Juniors |
| 2008 | B. Lucas | North Footscray |
| 2007 | M. Dorricott | Hoppers Crossing |
| 2006 | D. Mitchell | Western Magpies* |
| A. Maki | Werribee Juniors* | |
| 2005 | M. Ellis | West Footscray/Sunshine |
| 1995 | S. Maher | Flemington Juniors |
| 1994 | D. Phelps | Spotswood |
| 1993 | A. Saliba | Albion |
| 2008 | D. McMahon | Parkside |
| 1989 | J. Bouchard | Sunshine YCW |
| 1988 | R. Jimeno | Albanvale |
| 2023 | C. O'Connor Moreira | Point Cook |
| 2022 | K. Weston Turner | Spotswood |
| 2021 | S. Grieves | Yarraville Seddon/Flemington Juniors |
| 2019 | E. Sheehan | Melbourne University Women's |
| 2018 | M. Huta | Spotswood 2 |
| 2017 | S. Whiting | Wyndhamvale |
| 2016 | B. Stevens | Deer Park* |
*Combined WRFL/EDFL Competition
| 2023 | K. Philipps | Spotswood |
| 2022 | R. Hicks | Point Cook Centrals |
| 2021 | H. Cran | Spotswood* |
| E. Vitalone | Braybrook* | |
| 2019 | O. Burrow | Point Cook Centrals |
| 2018 | J. Goricanec | Point Cook |
*Joint winners
| 2023 | S. Bates | North Footscray |
| 2022 | T. Aukaha | Point Cook Centrals |
| 2021 | J. Goodier | Point Cook |
| 2019 | A. Dillon | Glen Orden |
| 2023 |
K. Shaw | Albion |
| T. Clifford | Spotswood | |
| 2022 | K. Greenwood | Albanvale |
| 2021 | A. Toka | Braybrook |
| 2023 | Z. Piccolo | Glen Orden |
| 2022 | A. Borley | Manor Lakes |
| 2021 | E. Rose Gelletly | Glen Orden |
| 2023 | J. Fuzy | Laverton |
| 2022 | K. Hanniver | Point Cook Centrals |
| 2023 | B. Hermansson | Point Cook Centrals |